A few months back, a blog by Brendan Caldwell was making the rounds on social media titled, “Death to the self-playing game.” The thesis was that titles such as Vampire Survivors were automating the process of playing a video game, robbing players of making any meaningful choices and removing individual skill from the equation. That’s an oversimplification of the article, but it’s something I somewhat agree with. While I enjoy Vampire Survivors, there comes a point in a player’s journey where their progression of power-ups out paces any challenge, leading to a feedback loop of only occasionally pressing a button to select which item to upgrade. You can go through a full-frontal lobotomy and still play Vampire Survivors well.
Almost seemingly as a response to this very blog, Auroch Digital’s recently released Warhammer Survivors asks the question, “What if Vampire Survivors was frustratingly difficult?” You know how the opening hour or so of any of these Survivors-likes (such as Ball x Pit, Loop Hero, Halls of Torment, etc.) is often wrought with you making barely any progress and dying a bunch? Imagine that for the entire game despite pumping coins into upgrades. It’s honestly kind of shocking how difficult Warhammer Survivors can be despite sticking to the “self-playing” concept that Vampire Survivors had. The game is relentless with its enemy onslaught and slow drip-feed of experience gems.
I wouldn’t say this is necessarily a bad thing. In some twisted way, I think the overwhelming challenge speaks to what both Warhammer and Warhammer 40,000 are about. These are worlds where war is a constant and heroes often put themselves into suicidal conflicts with a slim chance of survival. I’m more familiar with 40,000, so I can equate this idea to that franchise better. In both Boltgun games, Space Marine Mallum Caedo faces off against overwhelming odds not because he’s the greatest soldier ever (although he is), but because that’s just the universe he inhabits. The only way to break the cycle of war is to throw oneself into the fray and hope for the best.

A lot of fans miss the subtext of both Warhammer universes in that ceaseless battles waged by megalomaniacal rulers have ruined the planet. The fantasy Warhammer leans more into religious indoctrination and idol worship while 40,000 is more focused on how capitalism’s never-ending thirst for money has obliterated Earth beneath it. Both show the folly of man’s belief that they can control ultimate power, something history has repeatedly shown should not be trusted by mere mortals. I guess if the planet has made it to the 41st millennium, though, some crazed religious fanatics are bound to believe they can tame God.
Anyway, the settings for both games are the perfect series to expand Vampire Survivors to. While Vampire Survivors has grown to encompass more than just its own bespoke lore (you have expansions with Among Us, Contra, Castlevania, SaGa: Emerald Beyond, and Balatro), the way Auroch Digital has molded Warhammer into this framework feels seamless. Not much even needs to change apart from aesthetics, as the characters, weapons, and settings are an incredible fit. The thing is, if you didn’t make this game difficult in some fashion, would it even be Warhammer? That’s maybe the only apprehension I had before playing Warhammer Survivors, because Vampire Survivors’ difficulty is mostly in figuring out which weapon and item combinations lead to evolutions.
Well, Auroch Digital certainly brought the pain. It may have brought too much pain, because despite having already put 20 hours into just the Age of Sigmar portion, I barely feel as if I can finish levels. There are certain character and weapon combinations I can make that do “break” things, but it’s a serious test of knowledge, positioning, and luck to get there. I wouldn’t want Auroch to ease up too much on this feeling, but it does need to reconsider certain aspects of how it rewards players for putting in time. For one, upgrade chests need to fall more often so players can actually evolve weapons in a timely fashion. For two, certain evolutions wind up being worse than the base guns, so that should be rethought. I’m also not a fan of how tougher enemy types drop the same amount of XP as weak mobs, which means earning XP is less rewarding.

As for additions to the Survivors formula, I like the partner character mechanic. This was kind of toyed around with in Vampire Survivors’ various DLC packs (I believe Emerald Diorama first had it), but with some weapon types, your character will enlist the aid of another warrior to help them. It plays into the idea of Warhammer being a table top game by almost positioning these characters as figurines. Some of the weapons and upgrades do the same, with the D6 dice throwing literal dice onto the battlefield. A pack of glue is also used for a defensive bonus as if you are patching up a broken model. One level even takes place on a desk with a Warhammer mat, rulebook, and posters. It’s fun to see Auroch get so meta for this game.
The shorter level timer is an interesting change that could use some tweaking. Levels now run 25 minutes instead of 30, so players can expect a bombardment of enemies around the 12:30 mark instead of at 15 minutes. It means if you aren’t upgrading things properly, you’re likely going to die right at the half-way point. Boss fights at the end are also dependent on a specific weapon evolution that the level doesn’t tell you, meaning you’ll be doing a lot of trial and error before even finishing one… or you can get lucky. It’s not bad, in theory, but it would be nice to have some kind of idea of how to tackle these foes ahead of time. I would even suggest randomizing which boss appears where to keep players on their toes.

Another fun addition is that while both universes act as separate games, maxing out particular upgrades will carry over a bonus to the other universe. The initial system is identical to how it was in Vampire Survivors, with you pumping money into stats like Extra Health, More Frequent Shots, a Respawn, etc. If you focus on one universe for a bit, however, you can then start the next with a small bit of that power. Warhammer Survivors encourages jumping back and forth, even if I primarily spent time in Age of Sigmar. Having maxed out overall damage in AoS, I was able to make my first round of 40,000 go much smoother than AoS. Also nice: you can remove individual levels of an upgrade to invest in another, giving you flexibility in how you progress.
Getting back to the primary question I posited, “What if Vampire Survivors was frustratingly difficult?” You’d wind up with another slice of engrossing auto-gaming that demands way more attention and care from the player than the series it spun-off from. That’s not to say Warhammer Survivors is an automatic recommendation for fans of Poncle’s sleeper hit, but if you’ve never gelled with this type of game because it’s a bit too brain dead, Warhammer Survivors will radically change your opinion of things. Players may have little input overall, but Auroch has crafted an auto battler that manages to put a lot of action platformers to shame in terms of challenge.

Curiously, that makes reviewing Warhammer Survivors an almost impossible task. On the one hand, I do think this extra level of difficulty will sway opinions in both directions based on the individual player. For another, it’s so derivative of Vampire Survivors that I could practically copy and paste a review from Poncle’s game, change a few nouns, and call it a day. Did you like Vampire Survivors and have an interest in Warhammer or Warhammer 40,000? Then this is your game. Did you not like Vampire Survivors because it was too easy? This might be for you. Do you like Warhammer, but hate self-playing games? Then nothing here will change your mind.
Wherever you find yourself, I’m enjoying Warhammer Survivors while also being frustrated by it. Auroch Digital absolutely needs to rebalance some things, but the core gameplay loop is as engaging as ever. I just wish I could actually finish levels with some sense of regularity.
Check out more content about Warhammer
Warhammer Survivors content roadmap includes new characters, new weapons, and cross-save support
Leave a Comment




