It’s hard to imagine now, but there was a point in time where Super Smash Bros. was not a monumental hit for Nintendo. The N64 original is among the top five best-selling games on the platform, but it only moved around 5.5 million units. Perennial favorite Super Smash Bros. Melee was the best-selling title on GameCube and still only did 7.4 million units. While popular, it was never gang busters, and at the time of release, some Japanese press criticized it for not being similar to Street Fighter 2 or Virtua Fighter. That’s according to series creator Masahiro Sakurai, who spoke to Denfaminicogamer about not only Smash Bros, but originality in games in general.
When talking about the rise of Smash Bros. as a series, Sakurai was questioned if he had a desire to spotlight originality in design with the game. He responded, “I’ve already spoken about it quite a few times, but ‘creativity’ is quite low on the list of priorities when it comes to whether a game will sell or not. Even so, I still like to personally add something with an element of ‘creativity’ or ‘originality’. Otherwise, if it’s the same thing, you are better off playing the original.” He likened this to the Kirby series, which has a different flow and move set from Super Mario Bros. If Kirby was just pink Mario, there wouldn’t be much point in playing the game.
He mentions how even slight tweaks could cause players to think “something’s not right.” That doesn’t relate directly to Smash, but more an established series. “I expect Mario to have the style of ‘Mario-fun,’” he states, which is fair. You wouldn’t buy Mario and then get upset that it’s not a fighting game, for instance. Then again, he elaborates further by equating this to food. “I think this is relatively similar to when you eat food and the taste isn’t what you expected,” he said. “Even if there’s a unique deliciousness to it, a feeling of aversion comes before you can even notice it.”

Image source: Nintendo UK
How does this all tie into Smash? Sakurai outlines the properties that make Smash unique, such as its focus on larger scale battles, simple controls, and unique levels. “Think about if Smash Bros. had normal fighting game rules,” he explained. “In a 1-on-1 battle, you’d have guard, attack, and special attacks, and once your energy is depleted, you’re KOed and the match is over … even if it had been released, I think it would have mostly been seen as a ‘novelty,’ and that would have been the end of the history of Smash Bros.”
Obviously, though, those were the rules of fighting games when Smash first released. Developers hadn’t really attempted to mix things up to the degree Sakurai tried. As such, there was some backlash to this radical change in formula. “At the time though, it was criticized by people who couldn’t get into the differences it had from Street Fighter 2 and Virtua Fighter,” he mentioned. His overall point is that he wasn’t intentionally trying to be original with Super Smash Bros., but his desire to create a new game led him down a path which then introduced differences in gameplay approach.
Check out more content about Smash Bros.
Super Smash Bros. Melee becomes a 3D arena fighter in new mod
Rumor: Speculation swirls as leaker claims Metroid, Zelda, and Smash Bros. projects are in the works
Mario creator has no plans for a Nintendo crossover movie on a Super Smash Bros. scale
Leave a Comment


